What was the primary cause of the Newcomen engine's poor thermal efficiency?

Answer

Wasting energy heating and cooling the same large cylinder repeatedly.

The fundamental thermal weakness of the Newcomen engine stemmed from its operational method, which mandated condensation occur directly inside the main working cylinder. With every cycle, the massive iron cylinder had to be heated by incoming steam and then rapidly cooled by an injection of cold water. This process meant that a significant amount of the heat input energy was absorbed by the iron walls of the cylinder itself, raising their temperature, rather than contributing effectively to the motive force required for the power stroke. This continuous heating and cooling cycle resulted in substantial, unavoidable energy waste tied directly to the metal mass.

What was the primary cause of the Newcomen engine's poor thermal efficiency?
inventionHistorymachinesteam engineNewcomen