What was the most significant limitation making the initial tinfoil medium commercially unviable?

Answer

It could barely withstand a single playback before damage.

Tinfoil was far too delicate; indentations were often damaged beyond recognition after minimal use, resulting in muffled or distorted sound on subsequent attempts.

What was the most significant limitation making the initial tinfoil medium commercially unviable?
inventiontechnologyaudiosound recordingCylinder